Wednesday, November 29, 2023

The Begin-Sadat Center for Strategic Studies



 BESA Center Perspectives Paper No. 2,215, November 28, 2023

We cannot always prevent the murder of workers in an orchard or sleeping families, but we can set a high price for our blood. A price too high for the Arab settlement, the Arab army and the Arab government to pay. … [Retaliation operations] are not for vengeance. It is an act of punishment and warning, that if that state does not control its population and does not prevent them attacking us – the Israeli forces will cause havoc in its land.

IDF Chief of Staff Moshe Dayan,

Lecture to IDF officers: “Retaliation Operations as a Means of Ensuring Peace”, July 1955

(Published in IDF monthly journal Skira Hodsheet, August 1955).

Sunday, November 26, 2023

Israel Always Fights For Survival

The concept of war between nations is usually for land, control of a population, to acquire production assets or resources.

You might think one of these reasons drives Israel to war, but you would be wrong. Dead wrong.

We fight ONLY to survive.

Our forefather Abram (his name had not yet been changed by God) went to war with four Kings of cities north of Canaan after they took Lot—Abraham's nephew—as a spoil of war in their altercation with five Kings of cities around the Dead Sea who had rebelled and left the hegemony. They took Lot, and Abraham went to Damascus, defeated the four Kings, and brought all the booty back to the five Kings. He accepted no part of the booty for himself. He only waged war to bring Lot back home. Genesis: 14

God visited with our forefather Abraham (after He had changed his name) as he sat in his tents on the plain of Mamre. He told Abram that the cities of Sodom and Gomorrah would be destroyed because their sin had become grave. Genesis: 18. Abraham debates with God regarding the level of righteousness required to save the city of Sodom. Together, God and Abraham settled on 10 righteous men to be the city's salvation. This was a war of words in the form of a debate entered into with God in order to save lives. There were not enough righteous men to save the city.

Abraham and Sarah left Mamre and journeyed to the land to the south and settled between Kadesh and Shur, and he sojourned in Gerar. Genesis: 20. Abimelech, King of Gerar, found Sarah to be comely and desired her to become part of his household. Abraham had stated she was his sister. When Abimelech's people had all their openings closed so they could not give birth or even excrete bodily refuse, God told Abimelech this had happened because Sarah had been taken from her husband. God said that when Abimelech returned Sarah to Abraham the openings of the bodies of the people of Abimelech would be restored to proper functioning when Abraham prayed for them all. Abimelech spoke with Abraham and blamed Abraham for this "injustice" done to the people of Gerar. Abraham explained that he saw no fear of God in this place, so he feared that Abimelech might have killed Abraham to take Sarah. By saying she was his sister, his life was not endangered. Moreover, since Sarah was the daughter of Haran (the deceased brother of Abraham), the status of father for Sarah became the realm of the father of Haran—Terah—also the father of Abraham. In this sense Sarah could be said to be his sister, so he did not lie nor represent falsely. His statement did mislead Abimelech, who now understood and showered Abraham with money and gifts. He was not an evil man, however, and offered that Abraham and Sarah could choose to live among his people (Philistines) in peace. He may have hoped to create some form of commerce with such a man as Abraham. In this case, the possible threat to the life of Abraham caused the use of one of the tools of war—misdirection. At the end of the story, a treaty of sorts has been reached when Abraham prays for the relief of the people of Abimelech.

Sarah died in Kiryath-Arba, which is Hebron in the land of Canaan. Genesis: 23. Abraham requested to buy a plot to bury his beloved Sarah. The children of Heth told Abraham that they would provide any place he chose because they saw that he was a Prince of God in their midst. Abraham argued (almost like a propaganda war in the presence of an audience) with the children of Heth to allow him (Abraham) to buy the Cave of Machpela in the field of Ephron the Hittite. Ephron offered to give it to Abraham, but Abraham declined. He understood that this cave was for the burial of Ephron's family. It would be a great loss to Ephron who was offering it in the presence of the children of Heth so they would see his "gift" as making him an exceptional man. Abraham understood this and offered to purchase the entire field (including the cave) from Ephron. Ephron asked Abraham what would 400 silver shekels mean between them. This allowed it to look like he would give the field to Abraham—yet he had named the price at 400 silver shekels. Abraham understood the "saving of face" undertaken by Ephron and also the sale price. Since the silver shekel was worth 2500 times as much as the everyday shekel, Abraham paid 1,000,000 shekel for the field with the cave. In the presence of the children of Heth Abraham bought this field and cave in Machpeleh facing Mamre in Hebron. Abraham buried Sarah in the cave he bought for a great price from Ephron the Hittite. The cave is still in Hebron to this day. It is the burial place of our Patriarchs and Matriarchs. It is in the hands of the Palestinian Authority and is not available to us. So who is occupying whose purchased property?

I suppose we should fight to regain possession of our property rightly purchased in Hebron from the current occupiers. Maybe we can simply negotiate for its return to the proper owners.

Isaac was the son of Abraham. He was the husband of Rebecca (Rivka). Isaac was the son who was bound by Abraham and placed upon the altar of Moriah as an offering to God by the command of God. Isaac wasn't sacrificed but he was offered as a perfect sacrifice, and so he was intimately connected to the land God decreed to be the home of the descendants of Abraham. When there was a famine in the land, Isaac thought to go to Egypt like his father before him. God told him not to go to Egypt. If Isaac went to the land God showed him then Isaac and his descendants would inherit all these lands that were promised to Abraham's descendants. Isaac went to settle in Gerar. The men of Gerar asked after Rebecca and Isaac (like his father before him) said the woman was his sister because he feared they would kill him on account of Rebecca. Abimelech (King of Gerar) witnessed Isaac & Rebecca in the garden and knew they were husband & wife. He sent them away from Gerar and told all his people to leave them alone. They settled in the plain of Gerar and in the first year increased their wealth 100 times. Isaac opened again the wells his father had dug and the Philistines had filled over. Abimelech came to Isaac and told him to leave because he (Isaac) had become more rich and powerful than the people of the land. He was a threat to their peace. Isaac went to another area, and dug a well, it was not contested by the Philistines, so Isaac called the well Rehovot because they did not argue about it. He then went to Beer-Sheva, dug a well, and Abimelech came with Phicol (his general) to make a treaty (a pact) with Isaac. Since the Philistines had "done no harm" to Isaac, they wanted him to swear to do no harm to them. They made a treaty (which means without a treaty there would be a war) and Isaac named the place Beer-Sheba.

So if somebody comes to you with a General and tells you to make a treaty with them, wouldn't you think you may have been on the brink of a war?

In time, Isaac became old. He wanted to give his son Esau the blessing he could offer as the blessing of success and authority over the family and before God. Esau had already sold his "birthright" double-portion of inheritance to Jacob years before for a bowl of soup when he returned from a hunt hungry and tired. Now he also lost the blessing. He hated Jacob and decided he would kill Jacob after the time of mourning for the death of his father Isaac was finished. Genesis: 27.

Rebecca heard this and went to Isaac to say to him that she could not bear to have Jacob marry from the daughters of Canaan. She wanted him to marry a daughter of Laban her brother in Paddan-Aram. Isaac called for Jacob, blessed him, and sent him to the home of Laban the Aramean. Esau learned from this that the daughters of the Canaanites were undesirable, so he married Mahalath, a daughter of Ishmael, son of Abraham.

In this case, the war between the brothers Esau and Jacob was postponed for many years. Jacob preserved his life by leaving.

Genesis: 28.10-32.3. Jacob makes it to Haran, and asks after Laban son of Nahor. He meets Rachel daughter of Laban at the community well and is taken by her beauty. He asks Laban for Rachel to become his wife, and Laban says he should work for 7 years for Rachel, though Jacob can marry her now. Jacob is tricked, as Laban instead marries Leah to Jacob, and at the end of the 7 years worked for Leah, Jacob is allowed to marry Rachel and work another 7 years. He works 6 more years for an inheritance of the flock. His wage is changed by Laban many times. Much in the experience of Jacob with Laban proves Laban to be a trickster, narcicist, and thief. Jacob, his two wives and two concubines leave without informing Laban. He learns about the departure 3 days later. He comes with fighters to take back everything because he believes it is all his by right. He is ready to fight. He is angry.

Jacob assuaged Laban's bruised ego and shows how Laban has cheated him in every way. Laban realizes that God is guiding Jacob, and decides to make a pact with Jacob. Basically, if Jacob does evil to Laban, Laban will come for Jacob. This is a threat of destruction if you don't treat me well. The threat could go both ways, but Jacob had no intention to harm Laban unless he was attacked by Laban, so the treaty holds even though there is continual bad blood. War averted. Life preserved.

These are just too many words. I am going to revert to simple listing.

When Jacob reaches home, Esau comes to meet him with an army. He intends war.

When Jacob's daughter Dina is raped by Shechem, Simon & Levi (her brothers) circumcise all the males in the City Shechem and then kill them all why they are recuperating. Shechem—the son of the King of Shechem the city—had waged war on their family by destroying their sister's life, so they made war upon the males of the city in retaliation. Jacob is angered by their actions. There are other ways to make things right without resorting to war.

When Pharoah realizes the Isarelites are supposed to raise up a redeemer, he orders all the male babies to be drowned in the Nile river. This is an act of war—genocide. The midwives refuse to follow the command of the Pharoah—an act of rebellion. War against authority. War to save life.

Moses finds an Egyptian beating an Israelite. He kills the Egyptian – possibly to "save the life" of the Israelite. The text is not clear on this. Moses may not have been thinking clearly. He then escaped Egypt to save his own life, only to return 40 years later to save the lives of the Jewish people.

The Israelites are nearly assimilated into Egyptian culture, so God sends Moses to tell Pharoah to let the Israelites leave, but Pharoah refuses. God then wages war on the gods of Egypt in an amazing series of miraculous series of plagues, finalized by the killing of all the first-born of the land of Egypt. Certainly an act of war. The Israelites leave Egypt. The war of God saved their lives.

As the Israelites are leaving Egypt, the Egyptians follow with chariots to kill them or take them back to Egypt. God intervenes at the Sea of Reeds (or the Red Sea) and provides passage through the water for the Israelites, yet closes the waters over the chariots of the Egyptians, killing them. God makes war on the Egyptians to save the lives of the Israelites.

While the Israelites are moving through the Sinai desert, the Amalekites are attacking the stragglers, the weak, and the infirm. This is an act of war to take life. Later the Israelites will war with Amalek to save their lives. They take no "booty".

When the Story of Esther is read (each year at Purim) the Jewish people wage war against the followers of Haman the Aggagite (Agag was the king of the Amalekites) when given permission to kill those who are intending to kill them. They receive permission from King Ahashverosh to war with Haman and his followers because the original decree of the King to kill the Jews could not be undone. Therefore The King gave the Jews permission to fight back or even fight first. War to save life.

We have fought the Babylonians, the Assyrians, the Selucids, the Greeks, The Romans, almost every country in Europe, The Holy Roman Empire, the Ottomans, the Russians, the Germans, the Iraqis, the Syrians, the Lebanese, Hezbollah, Islamic Jihad, Al Quaeda, Hamas, Arafat, the Palestinian Authority, Iran, and the opinions of the majority of the world. We have never taken anything from any of you.

The ONLY land we have ever called home is the land between the River and the Sea. It is the land God gave us. Though we were sent away by the Romans and dispersed throughout the continents, we have always known Judea, Samaria, the land of the Philistines (Gaza Strip), and the Golan Heights are the majority of our ancient homeland. It is now occupied by others who have lived here for many years. We do not wish to force them to leave. They are welcome to stay and prosper with us. Alongside us.

We just want to live—in our ancient homeland—in peace. We are an ancient people. The last of the ancient peoples. We have learned to live in the modern world. We will continue to do so. Do not make us need to make war to preserve our lives. We will not go quietly into the dark of history.

All who are willing to live by the laws of the land of Israel may do so. Those who cannot will be prosecuted. There will be peace eventually. Let us make it happen sooner rather than later. Let us live in peace together.